Compare Products
Choose upto 5 items for side by side feature comparison
My collections icon
Go to collections
Filters IconShow filters
  1. Showing 1 - 36 out of 170 results for "best super soft peanut butter cookies"
    1. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Deweys Bakery Cookies Peanut Butter 8.5 Oz
      Deweys Bakery Cookies Peanut But…
      $5.59
      V
      Vitacost
      SALE
    2. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Soft And Chewy Classic Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe, Christmas Baking, Quick And Easy Dessert
      5
      ·
      2
      Soft And Chewy Classic Peanut But…
      E
      Etsy
      delivery truckFree shipping
    3. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients Single Pack Of Cookies (10.5Oz)
      4
      ·
      91
      4
      91 Ratings
      Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cooki…
      A
      Amazon
    4. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Back To Nature Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookies - Homestyle Soft Baked, Non-GMO, No Artificial Flavors, Delicious & Quality Snacks, 8 Ounce
      4
      ·
      4
      4
      4 Ratings
      Back To Nature Peanut Butter Choc…
      ($0.68 / 1 oz)
      A
      Amazon.com
    5. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Soft Peanut Butter Cookies | Chewy
      5
      ·
      1
      Soft Peanut Butter Cookies | Chewy
      E
      Etsy
    6. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Matt's Peanut Butter Soft-Baked Cookies - 14Oz
      Matt's Peanut Butter Soft-Baked Co…
      $4.39
      C
      cartnear
      SALE
      delivery truckFree shipping
    7. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Grandma's Cookies Peanut Butter 2…
      W
      Walmart
      delivery truckFree shipping
    8. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Super Soft Peanut Butter Cup Fille…
      E
      eBay.com
    9. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Peanut Butter Cookies (Peanut Butt…
      A
      Amazon
    10. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      5
      ·
      4
      Peanut Butter Cookies (RECIPE)
      E
      Etsy
      delivery truckFree shipping
    11. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      3.1
      ·
      15
      3.1
      15 Ratings
      Grandma's® Peanut Butter Cookie…
      K
      Kroger
    12. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      A+ RECIPE - Peanut Butter Kiss Co…
      E
      Etsy
      delivery truckFree shipping
    13. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      4.1
      ·
      30
      4.1
      30 Ratings
      Simple Mills® Creamy Peanut Butte…
      K
      Kroger
    14. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      3
      ·
      28
      3
      28 Ratings
      Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer C…
      K
      Kroger
    15. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      5
      ·
      4
      5
      4 Ratings
      Uncle Eddies Vegan Peanut Butter …
      ($0.67 / 1 oz)
      A
      Amazon.com
    16. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Classic Cookie, Peanut Butter Soft …
      W
      Walmart
    17. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      4.1
      ·
      59
      4.1
      59 Ratings
      Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwic…
      T
      Target
      delivery truckFree shipping
    18. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      4.1
      ·
      30
      4.1
      30 Ratings
      Simple Mills Nut Butter Stuffed San…
      $7.49
      V
      Vitacost
      SALE
    19. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Classic Cookie, Soft Baked Cookie, …
      A
      Amazon
    20. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Back To Nature® Peanut Butter Cre…
      K
      Kroger
    21. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Benton's Peanut Butter Filled Cooki…
      I
      Instacart
    22. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer C…
      E
      eBay.com
      delivery truckFree shipping
    23. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Peanut Butter Filled Cookies, 9.5 Oz
      W
      Walmart
    24. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer C…
      E
      eBay
      delivery truckFree shipping
    25. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      4.7
      ·
      60
      4.7
      60 Ratings
      Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies…
      ($0.25 / 1 floz)
      A
      Amazon.com
      delivery truckFree shipping
    26. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Peanut Butter Peanut Butter Chip C…
      E
      Etsy
      delivery truckFree shipping
    27. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      3.6
      ·
      14
      3.6
      14 Ratings
      Positively Peanut Butter Cookie! 3 L…
      ($1.25 / 1 oz)
      A
      Amazon.com
      delivery truckFree shipping
    28. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      1
      ·
      1
      Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer C…
      W
      Walmart
      delivery truckFree shipping
    29. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Matt's Peanut Butter Soft-Baked Co…
      $4.39
      C
      Cartnear gm
      SALE
      delivery truckFree shipping
    30. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Mightylicious Cookies Gluten Free S…
      $7.89
      V
      Vitacost
      SALE
    31. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      5
      ·
      2
      5
      2 Ratings
      Peanut Overload Cookies
      E
      Etsy
    32. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut B…
      W
      Walmart
      delivery truckFree shipping
    33. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Benton's Bentons Peanut Butter Fill…
      A
      Amazon
    34. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Positively Peanut Butter Cookie!
      A
      Amazon
    35. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      Grandma's Sandwich Creme Cooki…
      W
      Walmart
      delivery truckFree shipping
    36. Saved
      Save to wishlist
      4.3
      ·
      6
      4.3
      6 Ratings
      Peanut Butter Cookies
      E
      Etsy
    Oops! We are sorry, something went wrong.
    Continue your shopping by clicking on another product
    Product added to your wishlist! View wishlist
    Sign in to see your saved products on any device
    Product removed from your wishlist! View wishlist
    Sign in to see your saved products on any device
    Something went wrong. Please try again later.
    Product is added to compare already. Please refresh the page.
    Product is not found in compare. Please refresh the page.
    5 Products already added. Please delete existing selection to add this.
Feedback